Heroku Slug Sizes Impact Your Boot Time


Recently, I was trying to figure out why some of our projects were getting Heroku’s dreaded H20 errors when rebooting or deploying. When it’s starting new dynos, Heroku basically queues up requests it gets in it’s own routing infrastructure for up to 75 seconds while it tries to get your app processes up and running again. I assumed that this time only included the time it took to start my Rails processes. Not true! My processes took no where near 75 seconds to start and I was still getting H20 errors.

I had some suspicions and contacted Heroku support to confirm. Turns out I was right on the money. That gap is the time Heroku is taking to copy my slug (basically my code) onto the new dyno! The slug size of my slow booting app is about 270 MB!

So what can we do?

  1. We could leave Heroku to some other PaaS or run our own infrastructure.
  2. We could reduce our slug size, which was feasible in this specific case but might not be in all cases.
  3. We could enable Heroku Preboot.

The latter option isn’t actually wasn’t too bad of an idea. Preboot essentially boots up your new app for a few minutes before cutting traffic over to it, so you get true no-downtime deploys. There are some risks and downsides to this, but they are manageable.

We found that we were leaving around a lot of unused node_modules after we built our front end application. That dropped us about 150MB and dramatically sped up boot times. Whew!

⏎ All Articles